Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore My Properties
Youngs Farm sign beside a white house, with opening hours posted below.

Upper Brookville

Property Listings

Search Homes in the Area

Upper Brookville is not one housing market wearing one name. It is two, and the line between them was drawn by zoning decades ago, then defended all the way to the United States Supreme Court.

 

Upper Brookville is an incorporated village in the Town of Oyster Bay, first incorporated in 1932 to protect its properties, guide land use, and preserve a residential character that has never really changed: open space, winding roads, rolling hills, and wooded land. Its zoning code was first adopted in 1933 and rewritten in 1996, but the district map underneath it dates to December 1960, and that map created exactly two residential districts and nothing else — a Residence R1 District requiring two-acre lots, and a Suburban Estate OP1 District requiring five-acre lots. No commercial zone, no multifamily zone, just those two. About 2,000 residents live in 652 households across the village, and Planting Fields Arboretum alone covers 409 acres, roughly 15 percent of the village's land.

 

That two-tier structure is not an accident of the market. It is the law, settled by a lawsuit. In the 1970s, a developer who owned land inside the five-acre district sued to have it rezoned to two acres so he could build more houses on it. He won at the Appellate Division. The village appealed, and in 1980 New York's highest court reversed that decision, ruling that the five-acre minimum served a legitimate purpose in preserving open space. The developer petitioned the United States Supreme Court, which declined to hear the case, leaving the five-acre district intact. A two-acre parcel and a five-acre parcel in Upper Brookville are not variations on a theme. They are two different zoning products, upheld as such by the state's highest court, and each carries its own math for what can be built and what it will cost.

 

In Upper Brookville, buyers should look beyond the house to the land and the code. Even the portion of a lot where a house may actually stand differs by district: at least 30,000 square feet of contiguous buildable area in the five-acre district, against 15,000 in the two-acre district, with wetlands, floodplain, steep slopes, and setbacks carved out first. Accessory buildings are capped — no single detached structure over 1,200 square feet in the five-acre district, 2,000 square feet combined — and the code even scales horse-keeping to acreage. A five-acre parcel generally cannot be split into smaller lots; the only exception is a Planning Board-approved conservation subdivision on specific parcels, and even those must still meet two-acre standards as a floor. Ownership here also carries stewardship: drainage, mature trees, long driveways, and in many cases one of the village's 36 private roads, maintained by the residents on it. School assignment is parcel-specific, and buyers should confirm it for any address they consider. And before comparing two listings on price alone, find out which district each one sits in — in a December 2025 snapshot, active listings ranged from $2,250,000 to $7,488,000, and which half of the village a home sits in explains most of that spread.

 

For sellers, the two halves of the village price and market very differently. A two-acre home can move quickly when it is priced into its tier. A five-acre estate needs a longer runway to find its buyer — active estate-scale listings were sitting a median of 173 days on the market in August 2026 — and its pricing and marketing should be built for that reality, not for the faster half of the village. In a selective market, the listing is the first negotiation.

 

Thinking of buying or selling in Upper Brookville? Contact me for a confidential consultation — [email protected].

 

My Upper Brookville Sales

  • 1257 Pine Valley Rd — $1,219,000 (2017)

  • 43 Chestnut Hill Dr — $3,800,000 (2017)

  • 51 Linden Lane — $1,875,000 (2020)

  • 51 Linden Lane — $2,500,000 (2021)

  • Next to 77 Linden Lane — $1,640,000 (2025) (buyer's agent)

SHARE

Overview for Upper Brookville, NY

2,004 people live in Upper Brookville, where the median age is 52.8 and the average individual income is $134,357. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.

2,004

Total Population

52.8 years

Median Age

High

Population Density Population Density
This is the number of people per square mile in a neighborhood.

$134,357

Average individual Income

Around Upper Brookville, NY

There's plenty to do around Upper Brookville, including shopping, dining, nightlife, parks, and more. Data provided by Walk Score and Yelp.

2
Car-Dependent
Walking Score

Points of Interest

Explore popular things to do in the area, including Coffeed.

Name Category Distance Reviews
Ratings by Yelp
Dining 0.99 miles 0 reviews 0/5 stars

Demographics and Employment Data for Upper Brookville, NY

Population Households Employment

Upper Brookville has 652 households, with an average household size of 3.03. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau. Here’s what the people living in Upper Brookville do for work — and how long it takes them to get there. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau. 2,004 people call Upper Brookville home. The population density is 466 and the largest age group is Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.

2,004

Total Population

High

Population Density Population Density This is the number of people per square mile in a neighborhood.

52.8 years

Median Age

50 / 50%

Men vs Women

Population by Age Group

0-9:

0-9 Years

10-17:

10-17 Years

18-24:

18-24 Years

25-64:

25-64 Years

65-74:

65-74 Years

75+:

75+ Years

Education Level

  • Less Than 9th Grade
  • High School Degree
  • Associate Degree
  • Bachelor Degree
  • Graduate Degree
652

Total Households

3.03

Average Household Size

$134,357

Average individual Income

Households with Children

With Children:

Without Children:

Marital Status

Married
Single
Divorced
Separated

Blue vs White Collar Workers

Blue Collar:

White Collar:

Commute Time

0 to 14 Minutes
15 to 29 Minutes
30 to 59 Minutes
60+ Minutes

Schools in Upper Brookville, NY

All ()
Primary Schools ()
Middle Schools ()
High Schools ()
Mixed Schools ()
The following schools are within or nearby Upper Brookville. The rating and statistics can serve as a starting point to make baseline comparisons on the right schools for your family. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.
Type
Name
Category
Grades
School rating
Upper Brookville
Navigate

Explore Other Neighborhoods

Learn More

Follow Us On Instagram