Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore My Properties
Stone Hill in Muttontown, a red-brick home with a columned entrance and broad cobblestone driveway.

Stone Hill, Muttontown

Stone Hill is Muttontown's premier gated community — private estate homes and land parcels behind gates. Karen Sharf has sold 30 Stone Hill properties — 12 homes and 18 land parcels.

Property Listings

Explore Recently Sold Homes

Search Homes in the Area

Tucked behind gates in the heart of Muttontown, Stone Hill is one of the North Shore's most discreet luxury addresses — a private enclave of estate homes and generous land parcels where privacy is the amenity.

 

No one knows Stone Hill the way I do. I have sold 30 properties in Stone Hill — 12 homes and 18 land parcels. The lists below show my individual Stone Hill sales. The total of 30 also includes off-market homes and a bulk land sale. I even sold the original Stone Hill manor house itself. And my involvement didn't stop at the land: I worked alongside custom builders to develop some of the finest homes in the community. When a Stone Hill property changes hands — or rises from the ground — chances are I was at the table.

 

Stone Hill offers the Muttontown lifestyle at its most private: gated entry, mature grounds, and homes set well back from the road. Buyers here are typically upgrading within the Gold Coast or arriving from Manhattan for space, security, and top-rated North Shore schools.

 

Thinking of buying or selling in Stone Hill? Contact me for a confidential consultation — [email protected].

My Stone Hill Sales — Land

Stone Hill is a community I know better than any other agent in the area. In addition to the homes I have sold here, I have sold ten lots across the community, totaling $10,590,000:

  • 1 Somerford Court — $1,750,000
  • 60 Stone Hill — $1,467,500
  • 25 Stone Hill Drive — $1,450,000
  • Lot 67 Kingwood Court — $1,000,000
  • Lot 77 Mansion Hill Drive — $950,000
  • 1 Ardmore Court — $920,000
  • 73 Stone Hill Drive — $900,000
  • 3 Ardmore Court — $862,500
  • 29 Earle Drive — $715,000
  • Lot 32 Earle Drive — $575,000

My Stone Hill Sales — Homes

  • 35 Stone Hill Dr — $4,350,000 (2018) (both sides)
  • Lot 77 Mansion Hill Dr — $2,079,000 (2022) — later resale of the lot listed at $950,000
  • 11 Mansion Hill Dr — $2,940,000 (2022)
  • 14 Buckingham Ct — $3,051,000 (2023)
  • 5 Mansion Hill Dr — $5,725,000 (2024)
  • 6 Kingwood Ct — $4,000,000 (2025)
  • 25 Stone Hill Dr — $3,765,000 (2026) — later resale of the lot listed at $1,450,000
  • 10 Bromley Ct — $1,750,000 (2026) (buyer's agent)
SHARE
Stone Hill, Muttontown
Navigate

Explore Other Neighborhoods

Learn More

Follow Us On Instagram