Some villages announce themselves. Roslyn Harbor does not — and that is precisely its luxury. Tucked into the hills above Hempstead Harbor, the village once called the "Switzerland of Long Island" keeps its Gilded Age manners intact: winding roads, acre-plus grounds, and waterfront estates that rarely come to market and almost never advertise.
Early in my career, I sold the fabulous waterfront stone castle in Roslyn Harbor. I sold it twice. As I remember it, the house had literally been brought over from Europe stone by stone — and local lore whispered it had once belonged to Voltaire's mistress. I tell that part as lore, not documented history.
Roslyn Harbor is one of the few North Shore villages split between two school districts — Roslyn Union Free and North Shore Central — both rated A+ and among the strongest in New York State. Which side of the line a parcel falls on must be confirmed address by address, never by assumption; even a single street can straddle the boundary.
My Roslyn Harbor story goes back over 30 years, to the castle — and the recent record speaks clearly, in both districts. On the Roslyn side, 65 Bryant Avenue: a trophy property on 11 waterfront acres, two beautiful historic homes on one extraordinary parcel. On the North Shore Schools side, a wonderful home on Sierks Lane, a quiet cul-de-sac. A third recent sale shows the other side of the village: a diamond in the rough at 16 Mary Lane that drew 24 offers and sold $350,000 over asking.
In a village this quiet, a listing is a signal, not a shout. Come for the harbor, but buy with the parcel in hand — confirm the school district for the exact address, not the street. Roslyn Harbor does not chase attention. It rewards the people who know where to look.
Explore Other Neighborhoods